Thursday, January 18, 2007

A Puzzle

From an interview with mathematician Vladimir Arnold:
You take a spoon of wine from a barrel of wine, and you put it into your cup of tea. Then you return a spoon of the (nonuniform!) mixture of tea from your cup to the barrel. Now you have some foreign substance (wine) in the cup and some foreign substance (tea) in the barrel. Which is larger: the quantity of wine in the cup or the quantity of tea in the barrel at the end of your manipulations?
Arnold is strongly opposed to the Bourbakist style of teaching and doing mathematics. About puzzles like this he says:
Children five to six years old like them very much and are able to solve them, but they may be too difficult for university graduates, who are spoiled by formal mathematical training.